BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//CERN//INDICO//EN
BEGIN:VEVENT
SUMMARY:Power Prior's Weight Parameter elicitation via Bayes Factor-Calibr
 ated p-values
DTSTART;VALUE=DATE-TIME:20230629T103000Z
DTEND;VALUE=DATE-TIME:20230629T105000Z
DTSTAMP;VALUE=DATE-TIME:20261114T084707Z
UID:indico-contribution-1017@cern.ch
DESCRIPTION:Speakers: Roberto Macrì Demartino (University of Padova)\nIn 
 recent times\, the integration of historical data in the design and analys
 is of new clinical trials has gained considerable attention\, owing to eth
 ical reasons and difficulties encountered in recruiting patients. In the B
 ayesian framework\, the process of informative prior elicitation is widely
  recognized as a complex and multifaceted undertaking\, requiring the care
 ful quantification and synthesis of prior information into an appropriate 
 prior distribution. Hence\, there is a pressing need for developing techni
 ques and methods that can facilitate synthesizing and quantifying prior in
 formation more effectively and efficiently. Within this context\, the conc
 ept of *power priors* ([Chen and Ibrahim\, 2000][1]) has emerged as a popu
 lar approach for incorporating historical data into the prior distribution
  of a treatment effect\, in a flexible and controlled manner. \nThe power 
 prior methodology heavily relies on the *weight parameter* $\\delta$\, ran
 ging between 0 and 1\, that is a crucial factor in determining the degree 
 to which the historical data influences the prior distribution\, and for w
 hich multiple elicitation strategies are available. A modification of the 
 power prior allows a hierarchical prior specification by taking $\\delta$ 
 as a random quantity\n\n$\\hspace{4.5cm}\n\\pi\\left({\\theta}\, \\delta \
 \mid D_0\\right) \\propto L\\left({\\theta} \\mid D_0\\right)^\\delta \\pi
 _0({\\theta}) \\pi_0(\\delta)\,\n$\n\nwhere $D_0$ is an historical dataset
  with corresponding likelihood $L(\\theta \\mid D_0)$\, $\\pi_0({\\theta})
 $ and $\\pi_0(\\delta)$ are the initial priors for $\\theta$ and $\\delta$
 \, respectively. Furthermore\, a significant benefit of incorporating a no
 rmalizing factor in the power prior methodology is its adherence to the li
 kelihood principle\, as demonstrated by the joint normalized power prior\n
 \n\n$\\hspace{4.5cm}\n    \\pi\\left({\\theta}\, \\delta \\mid D_0\\right)
  = \\frac{L\\left({\\theta} \\mid D_0\\right)^\\delta \\pi_0({\\theta}) \\
 pi_0(\\delta)}{\\int_{\\Theta} L\\left({\\theta} \\mid D_0\\right)^\\delta
  \\pi_0({\\theta}) d {\\theta}}.\n$\n\nConsequently\, in a fully Bayesian 
 approach\, the ability to effectively elicit an appropriate initial prior 
 distribution for the weight parameter $\\delta$ is a crucial step. As far 
 as we know from reviewing the existing literature\, a comprehensive justif
 ication underlying the choice of a Beta distribution with fixed hyper-para
 meters\, that is an usual choice for this framework\, is pretty vague. \n\
 nThe Bayes factor (BF) constitutes a valuable statistical tool for model c
 omparison\; however\, we explore the use of the Bayes Factor to discrimina
 te between competing models that incorporate distinct initial Beta prior d
 istributions for the weight parameter by exploiting some BF $p$-value cali
 bration techniques ([Garcia-Donato and Chen\, 2005][2]). \nThis would enab
 le the selection of candidate models based on a more accurate and reliable
  assessment of the available evidence\, thereby enhancing the validity and
  robustness of statistical inference.\n\n**Keywords:** Beta distribution\,
  Clinical trial\, Historical information\, Robust selection.\n\n\n**Refere
 nces**\n\n 1. Chen\, M.-H. and Ibrahim\, J. G. (2000). Power prior distrib
 utions for regression models. Statistical Science\, 15(1):46 – 60.\n\n 2
 . Garcia-Donato\, G. and Chen\, M.-H. (2005). Calibrating Bayes factor\n  
   under prior predictive distributions. Statistica Sinica\, 15(2):359–38
 0.\n\n  [1]: https://www.jstor.org/stable/2676676\n  [2]: https://www.jsto
 r.org/stable/24307360\n\nhttps://indico.unina.it/event/67/contributions/10
 17/
LOCATION:Department of Political Sciences Aula Spinelli
URL:https://indico.unina.it/event/67/contributions/1017/
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR
